machines quite well; a rare, but enjoyable experience in modern politics.

Government, by moving away from its "grandfather clause'' policy for gaming machines and setting a firm date for an end to the machines has made it clear that it neither approves of the machines nor wants them in Bermuda.

At the same time, by setting a date for their elimination some three years from now, Government has ensured that no-one can complain that they have been unfairly treated.

The Opposition said that the date should be pushed ahead to this January 1, 2002. After all, if the machines are evil in 2004, then they are just as evil now.

While the United Bermuda Party's logic is impeccable, the Government is right in terms of practical politics and should have seen off the risk of any lawsuits in the meantime.

At the same time, both dates are arbitrary, and December 31, 2002 would probably have achieved the same end.

But Shadow Minister for Legislative Affairs John Barritt was quite correct on another point; Government should levy a tax on the owners of the machines right away. Then at least, the public can get some good out of them, and may be able to provide some help to the community which might at least offset the damage being done to the families of gamblers.

With every kind of tax seemingly on the rise, it is strange that Finance Minister Eugene Cox would not take advantage of this.

Apart from that, what is needed now is a full-fledged debate on a gambling policy in Bermuda.

Premier Jennifer Smith very ably put many of the problems associated with gambling on the table and Opposition Leader Pamela Gordon added more detail in her speech, as did other MPs.

What the debate made clear is that much about the issue remains uncertain.

There is still no clear policy on bingo or crown and anchor, not to mention the private casino in Smith's Parish which seems to operate above the law. In the meantime, many people see a legitimate casino as a cure-all for tourism.

Premier Smith said, rightly, that people who wish to gamble will. The question for Bermuda is how that can be controlled so that Bermuda benefits as much as possible and as few people as possible are damaged. That debate is far from over.