Hand to encourage thoughts about defence
All quiet down at the Bridge Club as the summer lull gets into full swing. A few players have taken the opportunity to attend the Can-At Regional in Halifax and no doubt another group will be getting ready for the ACBL Summer Nationals which will be held this year in Atlanta between July 26 and August 5.
I’ll bring you news of any good performances at these events — if you are attending either of these and have a good result, drop me a line.
Today’s hand is a bit of an old chestnut, but I love it for its instructional value in getting players to think about their style and defence instead of just following suit.
Dealer South N/S vulnerable
S632
H965
DAJ1097
C65
SJ954 S Q107
H84 H QJ107
DK52 D Q43
CJ1098 C Q32
SAK8
HAK32
D86
CAK74
It’s not often that every single pair gets to the same contract on a hand, but in this one all nine North-South Pairs ended up in 3NT after South opened a 20-22 2NT and North had an easy raise to 3NT.
The results were interesting — seven pairs made ten tricks for plus 630, one pair went down one for minus 100 and, most interestingly, one pair went down 3 for minus 300. How can that happen you say when declarer has seven top tricks? Easy, and it happened with both declarer and the defence doing all the right things.
First, let’s take a look at the seven pairs who made ten tricks. East usually led the Jack of Clubs and the play went the same way at all seven tables — declarer won, played a low Diamond to the ten losing to the Queen, won the Club return and repeated the Diamond finesse and made the contract with four Diamond tricks and two tricks in the other three suits — very normal.
At the eighth table, however, East ducked the first Diamond when declarer put in the 10. Look at what that does — it kills the Diamond suit. Declarer now had to hope for 3-3 Hearts but when that didn’t happen went down to a one-trick defeat, making two tricks in each suit. Great play by East.
Now to the table where the hand went down three. Sitting West was an experienced player who had seen this sort of hand before and at trick two when declarer led a low Diamond he put up the King. Again, look at the effect this has — declarer knows that taking the Ace will now also kill the Diamond suit and his only hope was that West had played the King from KQ or KQx, so he let the Diamond trick hold hoping for this layout:
S632
H965
DAJ1097
C65
SJ954 SQ107
H84 H QJ107
DKQ2 D543
CJ1098 CQ32
SAK8
HAK32
D86
CAK74
West now continued a Club which declarer won to play another Diamond to the ten. East, however, won the Queen and the rest was not pretty — declarer made no Diamond tricks on the hand and fell to a three-trick defeat. As I keep saying, is there any other mind game that is so multidimensional? The answer is a flat-out no.
Bridge results (the week of June 25)
Monday afternoon
North/South
1. Tony Saunders/Jean Johnson
2. Alan Douglas/Martha Ferguson
3. Patricia Colmet/Greta Marshall
East/West
1. Jane Clipper/Caroline Svensen
2. Diana Diel/Molly Taussig
3. Linda Abend/David Pickering
Monday evening
1. Alan Douglas/Jane Smith
2. Elizabeth McKee/Rachael Gosling
3. Peter Donnellan/Lynanne Bolton
Tuesday evening
North/South
1. Mike Viotti/Chris Harris
2. Samantha Pickering/Nick Kempe
3. Wenda Krupp/Joanne Edwardsl
East/West
1. Heather Farrugia/Michael Farrugia
2. Mark Stevens/Malcolm Moseley
3. Raymond McDaid/Inger Mesna
Wednesday morning
North/South
1. Louise Rodger/Elizabeth McKee
3. Peter Donnellan/Lynanne Bolton
George Correia/Michael Bickley
East/West
1. Stephanie Kyme/Jane Smith
2. Tony Saunders/Molly Taussig
Greta Marshall/Heather Woolf
Thursday evening
1. Richard Hall/James Fraser
2. Peter Donnellan/Martha Ferguson
3. Rachael Gosling/Simon Giffen
Friday afternoon
North/South
1. Stephanie Kyme/Jean Johnson
2. Janice Trott/Michael Bickley
3. Peter Donnellan/Richard Gray
East/West
1. Patricia Siddle/Julia Beach
2. George Correia/Heather Woolf
3. Elizabeth McKee/Diana Diel