Jury hears doubt cast on gunshot residue evidence
Gunshot residue that links an accused man to a shooting murder, according to prosecutors, may have nothing to do with it, believes an expert called by the defence.The trial of Antonio Myers has previously heard that one particle of gunshot residue (GSR) was found on a pair of partially burned jeans and one on a sock recovered from a bonfire, along with the accused man’s DNA.Another particle was found in some fire retardant sprayed on a T-shirt found in the blaze.The fire was discovered and extinguished by police in Middletown, Pembroke, on the night Kumi Harford was shot dead on nearby St Monica’s Road on December 5, 2009.Prosecutors say Mr Myers threw his clothes on the fire to destroy evidence that would link him to the shooting. However, defence lawyer Jerome Lynch QC called alternative evidence yesterday suggesting the GSR may not have anything to do with the killing.GSR comprises of tiny particles that are emitted from a gun when it is fired. They can land on the body and clothing of the shooter, according to American GSR expert Alfred [AJ] Schwoeble who gave evidence for the prosecution on Monday.They can also land on other people nearby or be transferred via contact between people and items, he said. He described the three particles found in this case as a low level of GSR.Mr Lynch suggested to Mr Schwoeble that the GSR may in fact have been carried to the scene by armed police officers who extinguished the bonfire. He asked him to consider a theory that the residue may have been squirted onto the fire from the extinguisher they used, which they got from the back of their armed response vehicle, which may have been contaminated by GSR.Mr Schwoeble said he would have to examine the extinguisher, but the particles would have to have somehow got inside its nozzle. He said it is not possible to tell how or when the GSR got there.“I was not there. I cannot say how it got there. That’s speculation,” he stated.Yesterday, Mr Lynch called on British GSR expert Dominic Miller, who gave alternative evidence for the defence.Mr Miller said: “Overall, the GSR findings do not assist in determining whether or not Mr Antonio Myers is connected or not to the shooting of Kumi Harford.“In my opinion, the GSR on the items from the fire could have been transferred from the armed police that attended the fire or their fire extinguisher and /or could have been deposited during the shooting of Mr Harford or deposited on another unrelated occasion.”Mr Myers denies murder and using a firearm to commit murder. The case continues.