Havens cost US up to $70b
WASHINGTON (AP) ? IRS Commissioner Mark Everson told senators yesterday that a trend towards a world economy helps wealthy taxpayers hide money in complicated transactions offshore, virtually invisible to tax agents.
?We have real difficulties finding out what?s going on,? he said. ?Our challenges are acute and ever-growing. Offshore abuses are a real problem.?
Everson testified to the investigative subcommittee of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, which concluded a yearlong study of offshore tax shelters. They determined that offshore tax havens offer the wealthy a ?black box? for stashing trillions of dollars, mostly impervious to tax, regulatory and law enforcement authorities.
The panel said the havens allow Americans to avoid paying $40 billion to $70 billion in taxes each year, with the help of ?an armada? of professional advisers.
Everson said some of the abuses could be tempered if lawmakers changed laws that can protect shelter users from some penalties if an attorney gives a legal opinion in favour of the transaction.
Integrity must be restored to taxpayers and the legal, accounting and financial services professionals that advise wealthy taxpayers, he said. ?There is a basic issue of honesty.?
One such adviser, profiled in a report the panel prepared for the hearing, wrote a virtual how-to manual for avoiding taxes by moving money offshore.
Lawrence Turpen retired from his career in dentistry and wrote a book about protecting assets by putting them in offshore corporations that appear unconnected to clients whose money they held.
He instructed his clients be careful about privacy and avoid a paper trail connecting them to their offshore arrangements, but Turpen?s own computer held documents about many clients that fell into IRS hands under a search warrant.
One of his clients told subcommittee investigators he could only respond: ?You idiot! That is exactly what you told me never to do.?
Both Turpen and the client pleaded guilty to tax-related crimes, and their case illustrates the common features of offshore schemes that the subcommittee explored.
The offshore industry uses countries considered tax havens because they promise secrecy and anonymity to people doing business there. The committee?s investigation examined offshore arrangements involving Belize, the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands, the Isle of Man, Nevis and Panama.
The arrangement typically starts with a promoter, someone who sells wealthy people on the advantages of moving money offshore and who recommends a country or service provider to those clients.
In the offshore location, local providers help people set up offshore corporations and trusts that receive the money moved out of the United States. They fill out paperwork, pay appropriate fees and do business on behalf of the client. The corporations and trusts they create become the new owners of money and assets that the client moves offshore.
Often, the service providers manage the trusts and corporations for a fee. They also hold paperwork offshore, while allowing the clients to continue controlling their money and assets.
This wouldn?t work, the report said, without lawyers who provide guidance to clients and financial institutions that allow access in the United States to money stashed overseas through credit and debit cards.
To address the problem, tax, securities and money laundering laws should be changed to presume that a US citizen should be taxed on money in a trust or corporation in a country known to the Treasury Department to be a tax haven, said Sen. Carl Levin of Michigan, the top Democrat on the investigative subcommittee.
That would put the burden on the taxpayer to prove the money should not be taxed.
?These outrageous tax haven abuses are eating away at the fabric of our tax system, and it is long, long past time to shut them down,? he said.
In another tax shelter, detailed in the investigators? lengthy report, $2 billion in capital gains were sheltered from taxation in an arrangement known as POINT, or Personally Optimised Investment Transaction, which took advantage of offshore secrecy.
Its promoters created the tax shelter by making billions of dollars in securities transactions to generate billions of dollars in capital losses, but the transactions were all fake, the investigators concluded.
They were nonetheless used by investors to offset their capital gains and erase taxes owed, and the government lost $300 million, the panel said. Promoters of the scheme told the investigators that the transactions were valid under U.S. tax laws.
Two wealthy investors who used the shelter ? Haim Saban and Robert Wood Johnson IV ? told the committee they relied on advisers and later found out it might be a questionable transaction.
?I was quite upset, to say the least,? Saban said.