Education debt is not always good debt
There's been quite a bit of news lately about how, as the credit crisis continues, it may be more difficult for some families to get student loans.
I'll be honest. I think if college students and their parents have a harder time getting loans, that's a good thing. Perhaps now more people will stop and consider the long-term implications of taking on so much of this so-called "good" debt to fund a college education.
The College Board likes to highlight in its annual survey of college costs that over a working lifetime, a college-educated person can earn considerably more than someone with just a high school diploma.
But many of those college grads are now using an increasingly higher percentage of their incomes to pay down student loan debts — for at least a decade after they've left school. Add at least another decade if the student attends a pricey, private college.
As the college financial aid award letters arrive and you sit down with your child, consider the dilemmas faced by the following people who wrote to me.
South Carolina resident Brenda Nixon is having trouble paying back about $58,000 in undergraduate and graduate student loans.
"Are there any programmes that you know of to assist borrowers with student loans?" she asked. "My forbearances and deferments have all been exhausted." As graduation season approaches, I'll get more questions like this one. That's when it hits people that they are struggling to pay back the thousands of dollars they borrowed. Many can't even handle the pint-size loan payments made possible by extending the loans out for as much as 30 years.
While there are some loan forgiveness programmes, they're generally available only for people such as teachers or doctors who are willing to work in under-served and low-income areas.
One Florida mother wanted to know how to help her 21-year-old son who has $45,000 in private and federally backed student loan debt. The payments on the loans total about $400 a month. And he's still attending school although he's not taking on any additional debt.
"Can he consolidate his loans and make the payments much lower so he can get his own place?" the mom asked. "He is willing to pay back the loan but cannot afford $400 and an apartment."
For all you parents poised to tell your kid to go to whichever college he or she wants regardless of ability to pay without large loans, consider the consequences of that choice.
A Falls Church, Virginia, father, who participated in a recent online chat, is trying to get his kid to be reasonable. He wrote: "Help! I'm a divorced father. My daughter could go to college for free the next four years in Virginia. She wants to attend school in New York where she will have huge debt upon graduation. She is a smart kid but doesn't understand debt."
Dad, do what my grandmother did when I won a four-year scholarship to the University of Maryland. I too desperately wanted to attend school out of state. To which my grandmother said: "No ma'am. You're going where you won't end up in debt."
I went to Maryland. To this day I'm grateful for my grandmother's tough stance. Not having student loan debt helped put me in the financial position to buy my first home about two years after graduating.
In the case of the Florida mother, her son could stretch his loans out to get an even lower monthly payment, but that means more interest charges. He shouldn't do it. Instead, I would suggest he keep living with his mama and pay off that $45,000 before moving out.
"Getting a college degree was always my dream, but if I had to do it over again, I would have probably foregone graduate school," Nixon said. "I'm not sure it was really worth it considering the cost."
Before you sign for those student loans, think about Nixon's regret as she reflected on her heavy borrowing for both of her degrees.
"Going into a lot of debt for my education seems crazy to me now," she said. "Even though some financial counsellors say education debt is good debt, it's not good to me."
Listen to Michelle Singletary discuss personal finance every Tuesday on NPR's "Day to Day." To hear her reports online go to www.npr.org. Readers can write to her c/o The Washington Post, 1150 15th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20081. Her e-mail address is singletarym@washpost.com. Comments and questions are welcome, but due to the volume of mail, personal responses may not be possible. Please also note comments or questions may be used in a future column, with the writer's name, unless a specific request to do otherwise is indicated.